I got:
Lost Season 6
One Tree Hill Season 7
Gossip Girl Season 3
Bones Season 5
My Name is Earl Season 4
Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles Season 1
Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles Season 2
Chuck Season 3
Samsung Blu-ray Player
Inception on Blu-ray
Halo: Reach
Stargate SG-1 Season 1 (had, but wanted a new copy)
The Batman Season 5
Community Season 1
The New Adventures of Old Christine Season 1
Star Trek: The Next Generation Season 5
Star Trek: The Next Generation Season 6
Star Trek: The Next Generation Season 7
Star Trek: Voyager Season 6
Star Trek: Voyager Season 7
Gary Unmarried Season 1
Spin City Season 3
24: Redemption
Red Robin: Collision
Batgirl: Kicking Assassins
Batgirl: Fists of Fury
Ultimate Spider-Man Vol. 19: Death of a Goblin
Ultimate Spider-Man Vol. 20: And His Amazing Friends
IDW's GI Joe Vol. 1
Amazing Spider-Man by JMS - Ultimate Collection Book 3
Slippers
A steering wheel cover
A 2011 How I Met Your Mother Calender
Blank VHS Tapes (yes, I still use those)
I also got money, a gift card to Target, and gift certificates to my LCS. Oh, and I got cologne and candy as well.